What Does a Warehouse Bailee Letter Say Before the Takeout Investor Funds?

In Fannie Mae’s description, before the takeout investor funds, a warehouse bailee letter typically says the notes are pledged to the warehouse lender, the lien releases only when the purchase proceeds reach that lender as the letter instructs, and the custodian holds the notes for that lender. The custodian holds them until the lender is paid or gets the unpurchased notes back.

Selling Guide C1-2-05 says bailee letters “typically state” those three points; it prescribes no required form. What it does not settle is who bears the cost of a failure as between the seller, its warehouse lender, and its custodian. That question is answered in your warehouse agreement, your custodial agreement, and Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). In our view, the answers are less comfortable than sellers tend to assume.

What does a bailee letter actually do in a warehouse takeout?

A bailee letter does two jobs in a warehouse takeout: it gives the custodian notice of the warehouse lender’s interest, and it asks the custodian to hold the notes for that lender. Fannie Mae reads the term broadly. C1-2-05 treats as a bailee letter “any communication that notifies a document custodian” that the notes are pledged, subject to a lien, owned by a third party, or subject to some other claim that, if not released, would leave Fannie Mae with “less than clear, unencumbered, and exclusive title.”

The UCC gives the warehouse lender two routes to possession of notes in someone else’s hands. Under the uniform text of Section 9-313(c)(1), in the version we read, the lender takes possession when the custodian “authenticates a record acknowledging that it holds possession of the collateral for the secured party’s benefit.” Under Section 9-313(h), a lender that already has possession “does not relinquish possession” by delivering the notes to another person who is instructed, before or at delivery, “to hold possession of the collateral for the secured party’s benefit” or to redeliver it.

Each state enacts its own version of Article 9, and we did not read any state’s enactment for this article. We describe the uniform text, and which state’s version governs your facility is one of the first things to confirm.

Why does the custodian’s acknowledgment matter on the first route?

The custodian’s acknowledgment matters on the first route because, where the warehouse lender never held the notes itself, the uniform text makes it the event that counts and makes it optional. Section 9-313(f) says a person in possession of collateral “is not required to acknowledge that it holds possession for a secured party’s benefit.” On that route, for Article 9 possession, a letter the custodian never acknowledges is a notice and little more.

Even an acknowledgment carries less than it seems. Section 9-313(g)(2) provides that, “unless the person otherwise agrees or law other than this article otherwise provides,” the acknowledging custodian “does not owe any duty to the secured party and is not required to confirm the acknowledgment to another person.” Section 9-313(i) says the same of a person that receives notes under the second route. The statute protects the warehouse lender’s possession. It does not, by itself, give the lender a custodian that must do anything in particular.

In our view, this is where takeouts quietly break. A seller may assume the custodian owes the warehouse lender duties that protect the takeout. Under Article 9, it owes the lender those duties only if it agrees to them or other law imposes them. If the bailee letter, the custodial agreement, and the warehouse agreement do not line up, the gap falls on someone, and the documents decide who.

What does Fannie Mae promise the warehouse lender, and what does it refuse?

Fannie Mae promises the warehouse lender very little in the two Selling Guide sections read here, and it refuses liability for losses and delay. Selling Guide C1-2-03, after referring to its procedures for title issues a bailee letter raises, says “[t]hese processes are intended solely to verify the accuracy of certain loan information delivered by the mortgage seller (and not to benefit any third party).” Both sections send the custodian’s bailee-letter processing requirements to Fannie Mae’s Requirements for Document Custodians, which we did not read. On mismatched delivery instructions, C1-2-05 says Fannie Mae “will undertake to identify mismatches and to achieve matches in delivery instructions promptly, in good faith, and in accordance with reasonable business practices.” That commits Fannie Mae to effort, not to an outcome.

C1-2-05 disclaims the rest. Fannie Mae “will not be liable for any losses that a mortgage seller or any other party incurs as the result of Fannie Mae’s actions or omissions related to these procedures.” C1-2-03 adds that if Fannie Mae learns of “any issues in which the rights of another party might impair its unqualified title,” including a bailee letter, it need not deliver proceeds under the seller’s delivery instructions until the issue is resolved “to Fannie Mae’s satisfaction and Fannie Mae receives adequate assurances that it will have unqualified title to the mortgages.” It “will not be responsible for the consequences of any delay in the delivery of the proceeds that results from its having to resolve an issue related to title to the mortgages.”

Between certification and payment, the notes sit with the custodian. C1-2-03 says the certified documents “must be ‘locked down’ under the document custodian’s control prior to Fannie Mae’s remittance of the purchase proceeds,” and that the legal rights of the seller “(or, as applicable, of its warehouse lender) are unaffected by the certification processes until Fannie Mae has remitted purchase proceeds.” The warehouse lender keeps its rights during that window, but not the notes in hand. The bailee letter covers that period.

C1-2-03 also disclaims ownership before payment. Fannie Mae “does not assert that it obtains ownership or title to the notes” until the proceeds are remitted, and if the transaction fails to close, it “claims no ownership interest in the notes” and requires the custodian to return them to the seller “or its warehouse lender, as applicable.” That return requirement is Fannie Mae’s, imposed on its custodian. Of the agency guides, this article reads only these two sections of Fannie Mae’s.

Who carries the cost when delivery instructions do not match?

When delivery instructions do not match, the seller carries the cost of the resulting delays under the Selling Guide, and the guide states the reason. A seller “is obligated to ensure that Fannie Mae takes free and clear title,” so it “must make sure that its delivery instructions match those of its warehouse lender before it delivers the mortgage to Fannie Mae.”

The consequence follows. The seller “will be fully responsible for any trading or settlement delays (including those Fannie Mae experiences) that arise as the result of mismatches in delivery instructions.” Running these procedures also “will not constitute a waiver” of Fannie Mae’s rights under the seller’s “representation and warranty that the title to any mortgage note it delivers to Fannie Mae is free and clear of any security interest, lien, pledge, or other encumbrance.”

A mismatch is thus a seller problem twice over: a delay the seller pays for, beside a title representation it already made. In our view, the seller most exposed to both is one whose warehouse lender, custodian, and settlement team each think another party owns the delivery instructions.

What can a seller negotiate around the bailee process in its warehouse facility?

A seller can negotiate the points where the bailee process bites in its warehouse facility: whether the custodian takes on any duty to the lender, who bears a missed or late settlement as between seller and lender, and what happens to notes that come back unpurchased. Against Fannie Mae, the guide fixes the mismatch cost on the seller. In our view, between the seller, its warehouse lender, and its custodian, those points are open.

Article 9 shows why. The custodian owes the warehouse lender duties where it “otherwise agrees” or where “law other than this article otherwise provides,” so the warehouse agreement and the custodial agreement are where those duties are written or left out. C1-2-03 adds that Fannie Mae’s bailee procedures “do not apply when the same corporate entity is both the warehouse lender claiming an interest and the document custodian,” because by signing the Master Custodial Agreement (Form 2017) that lender “releases any interest it may have in the mortgage notes when it takes possession of them as Fannie Mae’s document custodian.” Which structure you are in changes the analysis.

The trap in the default is that the seller already owns part of the outcome. In our view, a warehouse agreement silent on acknowledgment, settlement delay, and unpurchased notes leaves the seller carrying risks it has not priced.

The right allocation turns on facts only your documents and counterparties can supply. Does your warehouse bank also act as custodian, and did the notes pass through the lender’s hands first? Which takeout investors do you deliver to, how does the facility treat a loan stuck between purchase and return, and what does it already say about release and redelivery?

A bailee letter is only as strong as the agreement behind it.

A bailee letter tells the custodian whose collateral it holds, but the custodian owes the warehouse lender only what the agreements, or other law, require. Read the letter, the custodial agreement, and the warehouse agreement together before your next takeout. For the financing and custody sides of the same facility, see when a warehouse advance actually comes due and how a warehouse margin call is calculated. See also what a document custodian actually certifies and our warehouse and repo facilities practice.

About Goldsmith Associates

Goldsmith Associates is a leading provider of legal counsel to depository institutions, mortgage bankers, fund managers, loan servicers, and broker-dealers nationwide in connection with the purchase, sale, servicing, and financing of whole loans and servicing rights. Founded by Jason Goldsmith in 2015, Goldsmith Associates has represented its clients on 871+ secondary market transactions conveying more than $155 billion in mortgage-related assets. Visit us online at goldsmithpllc.com, email us at info@goldsmithpllc.com, call us at 833-4-GOLDSMITH, or follow us everywhere @goldsmithpllc. We are on call and at the ready 24/7.