What Should a Seller Negotiate in Its Agreement With a Document Custodian?
A seller should negotiate its agreement with a document custodian around four points: the standard of care owed to the seller, transit liability, cooperation and cost on a transfer, and the information it needs for monitoring. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac hold the seller responsible for its custodian’s failures. The guide passages read here set no general standard of care or indemnity running from the custodian to the seller.
In our view, custody is easy to treat as a vendor line item. The agency guides treat it as the seller’s risk. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide A3-3-04 makes the seller/servicer “responsible for the safekeeping of all documents required by Fannie Mae to be held by the document custodian and for all losses incurred by Fannie Mae because the document custodian it selected failed to perform its fiduciary responsibilities.” This article follows that sentence through A3-3-04, A3-3-05, and Freddie Mac’s Guide Section 2202.3.
Which custodial terms can a seller actually change?
The custodial terms a seller can change are mainly the ones in its own services agreement with the custodian, because the agency custodial agreements are agency forms. A3-3-04 requires that each custodian arrangement “be evidenced by the execution of a Master Custodial Agreement (Form 2017),” executed in the end by Fannie Mae and the custodian, with a copy returned to the seller/servicer “for its records.” Freddie Mac’s Guide works through a Tri-Party Agreement. We did not read either agency form, or Fannie Mae’s Requirements for Document Custodians (RDC guide), and nothing here describes their terms.
What the guides do describe is who pays. The seller/servicer “must pay all fees and charges of the document custodian,” and Fannie Mae “is under no obligation to pay compensation to the document custodian.” Fees are therefore set between the seller and the custodian. In our view, that services agreement is where most of the negotiable value in custody sits.
The agency paper also fences the custodian in, which limits what the custodian can promise you. Under A3-3-05, the custodian “must not release custodial documents for either whole loans or MBS loans unless it receives a written request (including in electronic form) containing substantially the same information as required by Request for Release/Return of Documents (Form 2009).” Section 2202.3 bars the custodian from any arrangement by which another party “would obtain, retain or claim any interest (including an ownership or security interest) in the Notes and any assignments or the underlying Mortgages, unless otherwise specifically and expressly approved by Freddie Mac in writing.” A services agreement has to work inside those limits. Section 2202.3 does have the custodian hold notes “in trust, for the benefit of the Seller/Servicer” when it receives a Form 1036 request for constructive possession, a case limited to Form 1036 requests.
How far does the seller’s responsibility for the custodian reach?
The seller’s responsibility for the custodian reaches further than the custodian’s own, at least in the two Section 2202.3 sentences compared here. The custodian covenants to “[i]ndemnify Freddie Mac for such losses as may occur as a result of any negligence by the Document Custodian” in performing its duties. The custodian’s standard there is negligence.
The seller’s undertaking in the same section is written differently. The seller/servicer “agrees to indemnify Freddie Mac and hold Freddie Mac harmless for any loss, damage or expense (including court costs and reasonable attorney fees) that Freddie Mac may incur as a result of the Seller/Servicer’s Document Custodian holding Notes and any other documents.” No negligence qualifier appears in that sentence. Read side by side, those two sentences make the seller’s exposure for the custodian broader than the custodian’s exposure for itself.
Fannie Mae frames it through the custodian’s fiduciary duties and keeps a direct claim too: it “may also require the document custodian to make Fannie Mae whole if the document custodian breaches its fiduciary obligations to Fannie Mae.” Either way, the agency has two pockets to reach. In our view, whether the seller can reach the custodian for what the agency takes from the seller is the open question.
What does the seller owe the agencies in monitoring its custodian?
The seller owes the agencies active monitoring of its custodian, and both guides spell it out. A3-3-04 requires methods for monitoring the custodian’s “financial viability and operational capabilities,” including at a minimum “an annual review of information about the document custodian’s internal audits” and “a quarterly review of the document custodian’s financial rating (or its parent’s or subsidiary’s ratings if the custodian is not a regulated institution).” If the rating falls below the minimum, the seller or servicer “must immediately notify” Fannie Mae.
Freddie Mac makes the seller/servicer responsible for monitoring its custodian’s compliance with eligibility requirements and for ensuring the custodian complies “at all times,” with stated exceptions for Designated Custodians and certain work performed outside the United States. If the custodian fails an eligibility requirement or violates the Guide or the Tri-Party Agreement, the seller/servicer must notify Freddie Mac “in writing within one day” of learning of it, and Freddie Mac “in its discretion, may allow the Seller/Servicer a period of time to work with its Document Custodian.”
Freddie Mac also keeps the remedy for itself. It “reserves the right to immediately terminate a Tri-Party Agreement,” and it may direct the notes moved to a Designated Custodian or another custodian.
In our view, most of these obligations depend on information the custodian controls, such as its internal audit results, and a seller that has not secured it is promising the agency something a third party controls.
Who pays when the notes have to move or are lost in transit?
When the notes have to move, the servicer pays the costs of a transfer it arranges under Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide, Fannie Mae may order a move on its own, and loss in transit turns on a Freddie Mac rule. A3-3-04 says Fannie Mae “may require a seller/servicer or document custodian to transfer documents to a different document custodian, even if the current custodian satisfies Fannie Mae’s requirements.” A3-3-05, addressing a servicer’s transfer of custodial documents, says the servicer “must make appropriate arrangements for the safe transfer of the custodial documents to the new custodian’s facilities and for the payment of all costs related to the transfer.” A3-3-05 also requires recertification on a servicing transfer whether or not the custodian changes.
Both sides of a servicing transfer carry custody tasks. A transferee servicer that will not keep the existing custodian must tell Fannie Mae when it sends Form 629, the transfer approval request. The transferor servicer must also give both custodians a data file with loan-level information for each loan whose documents are moving. In our view, a seller that has already agreed what a departing custodian owes on exit is better placed than one negotiating it while the transfer clock runs.
Loss in transit is a Freddie Mac rule we read, and it contemplates an agreement between servicer and custodian. “Unless the Servicer has agreed with the Document Custodian in writing for the Document Custodian to assume liability for Notes and assignments while in transit,” the servicer must carry transit insurance meeting the Guide’s minimum coverage requirements. The Guide adds that these insurance requirements “do not diminish, restrict or otherwise limit the Servicer’s responsibilities and obligations as stated in the Tri-Party Agreement or otherwise in the Purchase Documents.” In our view, the agreement replaces the insurance requirement and leaves the servicer’s responsibilities to Freddie Mac where they were.
What can a seller negotiate with its custodian?
A seller can negotiate the points where the agency allocation bites: the standard of care the custodian owes the seller, transit liability, cooperation and cost on a transfer, and the information the seller needs to meet its monitoring duties. The guide passages read here set no standard of care running from the custodian to the seller, and they contemplate a seller-custodian arrangement on fees and transit.
The evidence is in the texts already quoted. Fees and charges are the seller’s to pay, and so the seller’s to agree. Freddie Mac’s transit rule turns on whether the custodian has agreed “in writing” to assume transit liability. Under A3-3-05, a servicer that arranges a transfer bears its cost, so any sharing of that cost with a departing custodian is a matter of contract. We would expect a custodian’s own terms to address each of these points in the custodian’s favor.
The trap in the default is signing a custodian’s standard terms and learning only after a lost note or a forced transfer how the risk falls. In our view, the agency claim then runs to the seller, while the custodian’s responsibility to the seller turns largely on what its terms say. The right answer turns on facts only your documents can supply. They include which agencies and investors you deliver to, whether your warehouse bank also serves as custodian, whether you retain servicing, and what your current services agreement already says.
The custodian holds the paper, and the guides leave the risk with the seller.
In our view, custody can be outsourced, but the guides read here keep its consequences with the seller that chose the custodian. Ask what your custodian has actually agreed to before the next lost note, not after it. For the certification side of custody, see what a document custodian actually certifies and how to clear a collateral file exception before it kills a trade. For the servicing side, see what a subservicing agreement decides and our custodian and servicer engagements practice.
Goldsmith Associates is a leading provider of legal counsel to depository institutions, mortgage bankers, fund managers, loan servicers, and broker-dealers nationwide in connection with the purchase, sale, servicing, and financing of whole loans and servicing rights. Founded by Jason Goldsmith in 2015, Goldsmith Associates has represented its clients on 898+ secondary market transactions conveying more than $163 billion in mortgage-related assets. Visit us online at goldsmithpllc.com, email us at info@goldsmithpllc.com, call us at 833-4-GOLDSMITH, or follow us everywhere @goldsmithpllc. We are on call and at the ready 24/7.

